Thursday, September 27, 2012

WSH Alert – Worker Fell from Platform at Concrete Batching Plant

21 Dec 2011
 
A worker was tasked to hack and remove hardened concrete within the discharge hopper of a concrete mixing equipment. The equipment was located about 7 metres above ground with a work platform surrounding it. At about 12.20p.m., he was found dead on the ground directly below an uncovered opening on the platform. The metal grating for the platform’s opening was found removed.
 
 
 Figure 1: The concrete discharge hopper which the worker was working on
 
Recommendations*
 
Occupiers and employers undertaking similar work activities are advised to prevent recurrence by conducting risk assessment and applying suitable control measures prior to work commencement. Examples of control measures include:
 
• Replacing all easily removable platform floor gratings with permanently fixed ones to prevent unauthorized removal and eliminate possibility of workers falling from height through floor openings
• Documenting and communicating the safe work method for removal and disposal of hardened concrete  within the hopper – this include implementing a  Lock Out Tag Out (LOTO) system for the automated gate to ensure that the hopper discharge nozzle remains locked while the worker is carrying out hacking activity inside the hopper
• Providing sufficient supervision to ensure on-site adherence to the safe work method
• Barricading the zone directly below the hopper to prohibit access and protect workers and visitors from being struck by falling debris while hacking activity is being carried out in the hopper
• Posting suitable safety signages at the work location to remind workers of the job hazards
 
Further Information
 
1. Workplace Safety and Health Act (Chapter 354A), please click here
2. Workplace Safety and Health (Risk Management) Regulations, please click here
3. Code of Practice on WSH Risk Management, please click here
4. Code of Practice for Working Safely at Height, please click here
5. WSH Council’s Work at Height Kit, please click here
6. CP 91: 2001 Code of Practice for Lockout Procedure
7. Singapore Standard SS 508: Parts 1 to 4: 2004 - Graphical Symbols - Safety Colours and Safety Signs
8. Singapore Standard SS 528: Parts 1 to 6: 2006 - Personal Fall Arrest Systems
 
* Please note that the information provided is not exhaustive and is for the benefit of enhancing workplace safety and health so that a recurrence may be prevented. The information provided is not to be construed as implying any liability to any party nor should it be taken to encapsulate all the responsibilities and obligations of the reader of this WSH Alert under the law. 

WSH Alert – Workers Fell together with a Cherry Picker Basket
 
Incident
 
Two workers fell to their death while they were on a mobile elevating work platform (MEWP) to carry out abrasive blasting work on a vessel. They were in the basket of the MEWP (a cherry picker) about 25m from the ground, when the MEWP’s extended boom suddenly buckled. The basket, together with the two workers, dropped towards the ground and hit a keel block on the ground.
  

Figure 1: Workers fell together with the basket of a MEWP when the boom buckled 

Recommendations*
 
Occupiers, employers and workers undertaking similar work using MEWPs are advised to conduct hazard identification, risk assessment and implement appropriate control measures prior to work commencement. Examples of control measures include:

• Ensuring the MEWP is properly inspected and regularly maintained by a competent person in accordance with the manufacturer’s requirements. Inspection and maintenance records should be kept up to date.
• Establishing and communicating safe work procedures to the operators.
• Providing supervision to ensure on-site adherence to
safe work procedures.
• Ensuring operators are properly trained and are familiar with the performance and control of the MEWP.
• Conducting daily pre-operation inspection and functional checks of all controls on the MEWP before use.
• Ensuring the operating weight is within the safe working load limit.

Further Information
 
1. Workplace Safety and Health Act (Chapter 354A), please click here
2. Workplace Safety and Health (Risk Management) Regulations, please click here
3. Code of Practice on WSH Risk Management, please click here
4. Code of Practice for Working Safely at Height, please click here
5. WSH Council’s Work at Height Kit, please click here
6. Britain’s Health and Safety Executive Information sheet – Preventing falls from boom-type mobile elevating work platforms, please click here
 
Courtesy from WSH Council. For more information, please visit http:www.wshc.sg

Safety Advisory – Ice Cream Promoter Trapped in Supermarket Cold Room Incident

24 Nov 2011

In a recent incident, an ice cream promoter was trapped inside the cold room of a supermarket for about 10 minutes when she went in to get more supply. The ice cream promoter was subsequently rescued.

Recommendations

To prevent similar incidents, industry stakeholders with walk-in cold rooms installed on their premises must implement measures such as the following:

• Install an audio alarm system outside of the cold room in addition to the push-button door latch inside the cold room. This acts as a back-up in case the push-button door latch is defective. The button to activate the audio alarm system should also be illuminated;

• Install an independent lighting inside the cold room and the lighting should not be able to be switched off from outside;

• Install the audio alarm with flashing light to the outside of the cold room that will attract the maximum attention. Both the audio alarm system and independent lighting should be provided with a battery backup to ensure operation in case of power failure;

• Display signages beside the door, both inside and outside of the cold room, to indicate how to activate the push-button door latch, audio alarm system and contact numbers in case of emergency;

• Instruct employees/persons in the use of the push-button door latch and audio alarm system as well as the need to inform a supervisor or co-worker before he/she is allowed to enter the cold room;

• Ensure employees/persons are familiar with the location of the push-button door latch; illuminated button of the audio alarm system, lighting switch and emergency telephone. He/she must also be able to activate the push-button door latch from inside the cold room;

• Post a signage at the entrance of the cold room to indicate that only authorized personnel are allowed to enter the cold room;

• Install an emergency telephone inside the cold room to allow any person trapped inside the cold room to communicate with the management security office;

• Conduct regular inspections of the push-button door latch, audio alarm system, lighting and emergency telephone to ensure they are in good working condition.

Further Information

1. Workplace Safety and Health Act (Chapter 354A), please click HERE.

2. Workplace Safety and Health (Risk Management) Regulations, please click HERE.

3. Code of Practice on WSH Risk Management, please click HERE.

Courtesy from WSH Council. For more info, please visit http://www.wshc.sg





WSH Alert – Lift Related Incidents

28 Oct 2011

Recently, two separate lift-upgrading related incidents occurred within a week, when workers fell into lift shafts during work. One worker survived the fall in one incident while another was killed in the other incident.

In the first incident, a worker was tasked to install electrical panels at a riser located on the 9th and 10th storey outside a lift shaft. While marking out the positions of the panels inside the riser on the 9th storey, the worker fell through the unprotected lift door opening into the lift shaft. He managed to grab onto an existing lifeline meant for a lift shaft gondola and that slowed down his fall. The worker landed at the new lift car platform which was at the 1st storey. He survived with injuries to his head, neck and hands.

In the second incident, as part of lift dismantling works, two workers were lowering lift components from the lift motor room of a 12-storey building into the lift pit below. The items were lowered down manually, using a length of nylon rope. One stood outside the elevated lift motor slab beam, while the other stood inside it. When they were lowering a pair of C-channels (combined weight approximately 180kg), the worker inside the raised beam fell through the floor opening, landed in the lift pit and was killed. The deceased was found wearing a safety harness.



Recommendations*

Stakeholders involved in similar work situations can undertake control measures such as the following to prevent recurrence:

1. A Fall Prevention Plan (FPP) is a framework that allows for safe work at height through a systematic and organised method of identifying, managing and controlling hazards in the workplace. The details of the FPP are specified in the Code of Practice for Working Safely at Height.

2. Lift shaft openings should be guarded or barricaded to prevent accidental falls of persons or items into the lift shaft. Such guards or barricades should only be removed for approved work processes and must be replaced as soon as the work is completed or stopped.

3. Workers carrying out work at height should be provided with, and trained in the proper use of appropriate personal protective equipment. Fall protection and travel restraint systems need to be anchored to provide the intended protection for workers against falling from height.

4. Work out a safe method for lowering heavy items. In the second case, using a chain block or pulley system would have decreased the physical strain of lowering heavy loads. Alternatively, the load could have been reduced by lowering one C-channel at a time. Additionally, the worker might have been prevented from falling by working outside of the raised beam instead of within it.

Further Information
1. Workplace Safety and Health Act (Chapter 354A), please click here.
2. Workplace Safety and Health (General Provisions) Regulations, please click here. 3. Workplace Safety and Health (Risk Management) Regulations , please click here.
4. Code of Practice on WSH Risk Management, please click here.
5. Code of Practice for Working Safely at Height, please click here.
6. Work at Height Kit, please click here.
7. Code of Practice for Safety at Work (Lift and Escalator), Labour Department, Hong Kong, please click here.
8. BS7255 : 2001 Code of practice for Safe working on lifts, United Kingdom

Courtesy from WSHC. Please visit http://www.wshc.sg for more infomation

Sunday, September 2, 2012

WSH Alert – Worker Killed by Collapsed Brick Wall During Demolition

6 Oct 2010
A worker was standing adjacent to an L-shaped brickwall, which was to be demolished. The two lengths of the wall were connected by a reinforced concrete tie beam. While a mini excavator breaker was clearing debris from the base of the wall, the wall in front of the excavator collapsed outwards. The connecting tie beam then pulled down the other adjoining wall, causing it to topple inwards. The falling wall struck the worker standing next to it and pinned him under. The worker was brought to the hospital but he subsequently succumbed to his injuries. Initial investigations revealed that the wall might not be adequately anchored into its foundation.
Recommendations*
1. Conduct risk assessment: Prior to the commencement of work, a risk assessment should be carried out to determine the potential hazards and risks that might arise during the demolition work. Control measures and safe work procedures must be established to mitigate the risks, and be communicated and implemented to ensure the safety and health of the workers involved. The key hazard in this case was the wall that destabilised during the demolition works.
2. Cordon off wall/structures to be demolished: Personnel not directly involved in the works should not be allowed in close proximity with any walls or structures that are scheduled to be demolished; Working areas should be cordoned off.
3. Use props or wire ties: Whenever the stability of the walls/structures being demolished are in doubt, props and wire ties should be used to support the structure prior to and during the demolition.
4. Deploy trained personnel: Personnel operating machinery or equipment should be properly trained and should posses appropriate certifications. Checks should be carried out by the management team to ensure that all workers and operators are properly trained and certified to carry out the works assigned to them.
Further Information
Courtesy from WSHC. Please visit http://www.wshc.sg for more infomation

WSH Alert – Worker Fell while Plastering Wall at the Ledge of Balcony

28 Sep 2010
Incident
In this incident, a worker was found dead on the ground floor of a construction site. Preliminary investigations revealed that the worker was carrying out plastering works at the balcony area within a unit on the 17th storey. The worker was found without any fall protection equipment and it was suspected that the worker fell from the edge of the balcony and landed on the ground. The guardrails that were installed were dislodged at one end.

Figure 1: Worker fell from the 17th storey balcony while carrying out plastering work
A similar incident had occurred earlier this year. A worker carrying out plastering work on the external wall of an air conditioning ledge fell to his death from the 9th floor of a building.
Recommendations*
1. Conduct risk Assessment: A risk assessment must be carried out by experienced and knowledgeable persons before starting any work. Through the risk assessment, employers and workers can identify hazards and take appropriate actions to eliminate the hazard or reduce the risks involved. Control measures and safe work procedures must be established, communicated and implemented to ensure the safety and health of the workers. In these cases, one of the key control measures would be to prevent workers from falling while working at height.
2. Establish workplace safety and health management programme and safe work procedures: Employers should establish and implement a safety and health management system with proper control measures and the appropriate safe work procedures. This includes an effective fall protection plan (FPP) for any work that may subject workers to the risk of falling from height. The fall protection plan must be clearly communicated to all levels of personnel, such as through refresher courses or daily toolbox meetings. It is also crucial to ensure that the safe work procedures are adhered to by all sub-contractors to better manage the safety and health of all workers at the workplace.
3. Fall prevention/protection: Work at height must be made safe through fall prevention or protection measures. Examples include installing guard rails that prevent persons from falling over open sides, as well as travel restraint, fall arrest or engineered systems with anchorage points as explained below:
  • Travel Restraint: A travel restraint system prevents a worker from falling by restricting his body movement into hazardous areas, such as open sides. For such a system, a restraint belt or full body harness is suitable once anchored securely.
  • Fall Arrest: An individual fall arrest system protects the worker by stopping his fall sp that he does not strike the ground. A full body harness with a self-retracting lifeline or a shock absorber and a lanyard are suitable for fall arrest once anchored securely.
  • Engineered Systems: Engineered systems such as horizontal lifelines should be installed according to the design by the professional engineer. Deviating from the design can result in the system no functioning as it rightfully should and can result in potentially unsafe conditions for workers.
4. Ensure proper supervision: Employers should ensure that workers adhere to the established safe work procedures, e.g. by ensuring that workers follow the fall protection plan when working at height and disciplining workers who perform unsafe acts and do not comply with the safe work procedures.
Further Information
1. Workplace Safety and Health Act (Chapter 354A), please click here
2. Workplace Safety and Health (General Provisions) Regulations, please click here
3. Workplace Safety and Health (Risk Management) Regulations, please click here
4. Workplace Safety and Health (Construction) Regulations, please click here
5. Code of Practice for Working Safely at Height, please click here
6. Singapore Standard SS 528 – 1: 2006 Personal Fall Arrest Systems – Full-body harnesses
7. Singapore Standard SS 528 – 1: 2006 Personal Fall Arrest Systems – Lanyards and energy absorbers
8. Singapore Standard SS 528 – 1: 2006 Personal Fall Arrest Systems – Self-retracting lifelines
9. Singapore Standard SS 528 – 1: 2006 Personal Fall Arrest Systems – Connectors with self-closing and self-locking gates
Courtesy from WSHC. Please visit http://www.wshc.sg for more information.

WSH Alert - A Case of Electric Shock

13 Sep 2010
Incident
In a recent incident, a supervisor on night shift duty was installing an electrical device. While performing the job, he did not use the voltage tester nor put on rubber gloves. A short circuit occurred which was followed by a discharge. The supervisor suffered a mild electric shock.
Recommendations
1. Conduct risk assessment: Before the start of any work, risk assessment must be conducted to identify potential hazards. Appropriate control measures should then be taken to eliminate the hazards or reduce the risks involved. The hazard relevant to this incident was the exposed electrical components that were still “live”.
2. Use of dry rubber insulating mat: Dry rubber insulating mat should be used where there is risk of electrocution. The rubber mat insulates the ground on which the worker stands, reducing the risk of electric current flow through him.
3. Provision of adequate training: All workers should be adequately trained in the identification and control of hazards at the workplace. Specialised electrical safety training must be provided to workers who need to work with or around exposed components of electric circuits. The training should include, but not be limited to, basic electrical theory, proper safe work procedures, hazard awareness, identification and control, proper use of personal protective equipment, proper lockout/ tagout procedures, first aid and rescue procedures. Provisions should also be made for periodic re-training or refresher training.
4. Lockout/ Tagout (LOTO): LOTO procedures should be established and implemented for the inspection, maintenance and repair of any machinery or equipment. All energy sources associated with the machinery or equipment should be isolated, disconnected or discharged to prevent the whole or part thereof of the machinery or equipment from being activated or energised.
5. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE): Appropriate PPE should be provided and used by workers who are potentially exposed to “live” components. These PPE can include electrical resistance or insulating rubber hand gloves and rubber-soled boots.
Further Information
1. Workplace Safety and Health Act, please click HERE.
2. Workplace Safety and Health (General Provisions) Regulations, please click HERE.
3. Electricity Act, please click HERE.
4. Electricity (Electrical Workers) Regulations, please click HERE.
6. Singapore Standard CP 5 : 1998. Code of Practice for Electrical Installations

Courtesy from WSHC. Please visit http://www.wshc.sg for more information.

WSH Alert – 2 Workers Fell to their Deaths

8 Sep 2010
Incident
On 6 Sep 2010 at about 1700hrs, two workers fell about 9 storeys from a building while working from the inside of a customised building maintenance gondola. Preliminary investigations revealed that the two men had fallen together with the gondola. They were pronounced dead at the scene by paramedics.
Recommendations*
1. Conduct risk assessment: Proper risk assessment must be carried out by experienced and knowledgeable persons before starting any work. Through the risk assessment, employers and workers can identify hazards and take appropriate actions to eliminate the hazards or reduce the risks involved. Control measures and safe work procedures must be established, communicated and implemented to ensure the safety and health of the workers. In this case, the general condition of the gondola, including the rail and trolley wheels, should be inspected before work is carried out. IN the event of any anomaly while operating the gondola, all work should cease immediately and proper recovery actions should be effected.
2. Establish workplace safety and health management programme: Employers should establish and implement a safety management system with proper control measures and the appropriate safe work procedures. This includes an effective fall protection plan for any works that may subject workers to the risk of falling from height. The safety and health programme must be clearly communicated to all levels of personnel, such as through refresher courses or daily toolbox meetings.

3. Implement fall prevention / protection / arrest system: Works that are carried out at height must be made safe through proper fall prevention or protection measures. This includes ensuring safe access and egress, and barricading or guarding all work areas to prevent falls. Fall arrest, travel restraint and engineered systems with appropriate anchorage points should also be provided:
  • Travel restraint: A travel restraint system prevents the worker from falling by restricting his movement into hazardous areas, such as open sides. The restraint belt or full body harness must be anchored securely.
  • Fall Arrest: An individual fall arrest system protects the worker by stopping his fall so that he does not strike the ground. The full body harness with a self-retracting lifeline or a shock absorber and a lanyard must be anchored securely.
  • Engineered Systems: Engineered systems such as horizontal lifelines should be installed according to the design by a professional engineer. Deviating from the design can result in the system not functioning as it should and can be unsafe.
4. Ensure proper supervision: Employers should ensure that workers adhere to the established safe work procedures, e.g. by ensuring that workers follow the fall protection plan when working at height and disciplining workers who exhibit unsafe acts and do not comply with the safe work procedures.
Further Information
1. Workplace Safety and Health Act (Chapter 354A), please click HERE
2. Workplace Safety and Health (General Provisions) Regulations, please click HERE
3. Workplace Safety and Health (Risk Management) Regulations, please click
HERE
4. Workplace Safety and Health (Construction) Regulations, please click
HERE
5. Code of Practice for Working Safely at Height, please click
HERE
6. Singapore Standard SS 528 – 1: 2006 Personal Fall Arrest Systems - Full-body harnesses
7. Singapore Standard SS 528 – 2: 2006 Personal Fall Arrest Systems - Lanyards and energy absorbers
8. Singapore Standard SS 528 – 3: 2006 Personal Fall Arrest Systems - Self-retracting lifelines
9. Singapore Standard SS 528 – 5: 2006 Personal Fall Arrest Systems - Connectors with self-closing and self-locking gates
* Please note that the information provided is not exhaustive and for the benefit of enhancing workplace safety and health so that a similar recurrence may be prevented. The information provided is not to be construed as implying any liability to any party nor should it be taken to encapsulate all the responsibilities and obligations of the reader of WSH Alert under the law.
 
Courtesy from WSHC. Please visit http://www.wshc.sg for more information.

LLCR – Toppling of Stacked Boom Section in a Crane Maintenance Workshop

17 Aug 2010

Incident
On the incident date in June 2007, a group of workers were dismantling a telescopic boom into its individual sections using an overhead travelling crane. After stacking a dismantled boom on top of another boom section, the Crane Operator began to hoist the chain slings away. As the slings were being hoisted away, the stacked boom toppled onto a nearby worker. He succumbed to his injuries.
Summary of Findings
Investigation revealed that the incident occurred primarily due to the negligence of Man (Crane Operator and Worker). The Crane Operator did not do his due diligence to ensure that the chain slings were free from entanglement before hoisting away. The worker should have positioned himself in a safe location, away from the lifting zone.
Management also did not establish the necessary safe work procedure for the stacking of boom sections. All these led to the occurrence of this fatal incident.
For more details and information, click HERE for the Lessons Learnt Case Report where lapses in safety and recommendations have been highlighted to prevent similar accident from happening.
Courtesy from WSHC - Please visit http://www.wshc.sg for more information.

Lesson Learn Case Report (LLCR) – Collapse of Crane Due to Overloading

13 Jul 2010
Incident
In this incident, a mobile crane was deployed to carry out lifting work at a two-storey terrace house. While the Crane Operator was lifting a bag of sand to the designated location at the rear side of the roof, the crane’s Overload Radius Indicator (ORI) alarm sounded. The crane then toppled, and its boom crashed onto the roof of an adjoining house unit. The crane eventually came to rest on its side, with the Crane Operator inside the operator’s cabin. There were no injuries in this incident.
Summary of Findings
Investigations revealed that when the ORI alarm sounded and the cut-off was activated, the Crane Operator by-passed the cut-off by switching off the Automated Moment Limiter. He continued to lower the boom over the roof. This unsafe behaviour led to the collapse of the crane.
For more details and information, click Here for the Lessons Learnt Case Report where lapses in safety and recommendations are highlighted to prevent similar accident from happening.
 
For more info, please visit http://www.wshc.sg

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

First Restaurant Convicted under the WSH Act for Workplace Safety and Health Lapses - WSHC & Bulletin

9 Jul 2010

Raffles Marina Ltd was fined $80,000 today for its failure to take reasonably practicable measures to ensure workplace safety and health, thereby contributing to the death of a worker on 29 May 2009. Raffles Marina Ltd is the first restaurant to be convicted under the WSH Act since it was extended to cover restaurants from 1 March 2008

About the case


The incident happened on 29 May 2009 at Marina Bistro Coffee House located at 10 Tuas West Drive. The worker was a senior steward employed by Raffles Marina Ltd. The worker was likely to have either slipped due to the slippery floor or fallen when he stepped on one of the articles strewn on the kitchen floor of the dish washing area. He was carrying at least one plastic rack containing 25 glass wine goblets. The wine goblets shattered and cut the worker in the neck area. The worker was sent to the hospital where he died from excessive loss of blood as a result of a deep cut on the neck.

Investigations by the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) showed that the employer had failed to take reasonably practicable measures to ensure that the workplace was safe and without risks. The employer failed to conduct risk assessment to identify and manage the hazards for the dishwashing activities. The employer also failed to ensure the kitchen was free from slipping and tripping hazards. Although the employer had issued a pair of safety boots to the worker for his use during the course of his work, it was insufficient to prevent the worker from falling.

Mr Heng Chiang Gnee, Deputy Chairman, Workplace Safety and Health Council said, “The death of a worker in the course of carrying out simple kitchen work shows that we must never take the safety at workplaces lightly. Employers must plan safe work procedures for all types of work, ensure that their workers are well briefed and implement safety measures effectively. Often, near misses during work, such as a slip at work, are not noted and no suitable immediate actions are taken to reduce risks and improve situations . To improve our safety management, there is a need to change mindset to seek out near misses and drive improvements even though near misses may not result in injuries. We should therefore all be mindful of the possible risks that our employees face everyday at work. If there are incidents or near-miss cases, measures must immediately be taken to prevent them from happening again. The Council urges all parties to pay serious attention to near-miss cases, or seemingly minor incidents, so that necessary steps can be taken to improve. With this mindset, we can then aim for safer workplaces for all our employees."

Mr Ho Siong Hin, Commissioner for Workplace Safety and Health, MOM added that the conviction of Raffles Marina Ltd serves as a stern warning to all workplaces to make safety and health a priority. He reminded all employers, individuals and stakeholders of the importance of ensuring and adhering to proper safety measures.

Please visit http://www.wshc.sg/ for more info.